Intersectional Ecofeminism

Intersections

“Integrating one’s past, present, and future into a cohesive, unified sense of self is a complex task that begins in adolescence and continues for a lifetime…” (Tatum p 10). The majority of women around the globe have multiple “isms” they must navigate throughout their lifetimes. Growing up in the 1960’s and 70’s, I had to contend with sexism, racism, classism and whatever word can be used to describe adult family members telling you that you are ‘not human enough to have a voice’. These constraints rear up from time to time, even years later. Today I still deal with sexism and now, ageism (even Covid19 has decided to discriminate against my age group). It’s not unique to me or women like me. I was born at a time when misogyny was rampant. My father was a misogynist, making sexist jokes at his daughters and wife’s expense. Adolescence caused me to slump over to hide my budding womanhood from my father and other males. Treating my mother brutally, she tried to learn when and how to speak and was often surprised at my father’s violence. The daily fear was palpable. Did I learn how to live with that injustice and violence? Hell no, I did not. What I did learn was that I would never be victimized like my mother was. That was an invaluable lesson that I passed on to my daughters, unapologetically.

Both of my daughters are Intersectional feminists. I have come to understand and accept intersectionality as my place in feminist history as well. “The cornerstone of intersectional theory echoes the sentiment of the oft-quoted phrase . . . by Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. that ‘No one is free until we are all free’. This phrase . . . captured the spirit of a generation, highlighting the inability of white or black people to be truly free until the other is. Intersectional ecofeminism builds upon this foundation by further postulating that the ‘freedom’ of humanity is not only reliant on the freedom of nature and women, but it is also reliant on the achievement of liberation for all of those at intersecting points on along these fault lines. Intersectionality has become a powerful tool when applied to ecofeminist analysis of the relationship between women and the environment, particularly in its ability to assist in furthering our understanding of how a person’s relationship with the environment (in the Global South or North) is not completely dependent on any one aspect of their lives, whether gender, race, class, sexuality or age but rather a combination of all of the above and more besides.” (Kings).

It is my intention, by taking courses like this one, to expand and include all women, and men, in the process of coming to terms with our exclusionary past as white women, to bring to the forefront the intersectionality of black and brown women. I am a fan of the podcast, https://www.tnqshow.com/watch where the three hosts (two black women) discuss how it’s time for white women to come forward and ask, ‘What can I do to help your fight, your struggle? What do you require from me?’ Intersectional inclusion means that I listen to your needs, our differences, and have compassion for your pain and come to understand that we are not the same, but we are human beings. We do not have the same isms that manifest the same way. My sexism shows up differently than the sexism toward a woman of color from the south. Understanding that is a key to working toward ways to end that sexism. “There is no hierarchy of oppressions. The thread and threat of violence runs through all of the isms. There is a need to acknowledge each other’s pain, even as we attend to our own” (Tatum p13).

“Intersectional ecofeminist work has been particularly prominent in research concerning both climate change and human relations with the non-human other; recent work has highlighted the uneven distribution of environmental burdens and the necessity of incorporating species into intersectionality” (Kings). Nowhere is this more of an urgent crisis than in the factory farming industry. Until this practice is halted and animals are treated humanely will it begin to change everywhere. “If you identify as an ecofeminist you’re not only a feminist, but also a universal ally for environmentalism, civil rights, LGBTQ rights, and any other movement that aims to reinforce the needs of marginalized groups —and that is the beauty of intersectional ecofeminism” ( Villalobos).

Majora Carter

Majora Carter

Majorca Carter’s TedTalk is a striking example of what one individual can do to mobilize a group of people to change their environment. Her passion and commitment is contagious and that’s what is needed to make a difference. Our planet is at a tipping point and environmental justice warriors like Ms. Carter are desperately in short supply. The fact that black communities bare the burden of power plants and waste facilities 50% more likely in their neighborhoods should astound white communities and cause them to work toward a more equitable distribution. The injustice of saddling poor neighborhoods with no parks, more detrimental industries and far less public funds, in this day and age, seems unfathomable. “Economic degradation begets environmental degradation begets social degradation” she states in her talk. Decades of these injustices, piled one on top of the other, require decades of dismantling and drastic policy changes. Providing green spaces where the neighborhood can walk, run, bike and socialize cuts dramatically down on crime, littering and abandoned housing because neighbors meet neighbors and look out for one another. “As we nurture the natural environment, it’s abundance will give us back even more.” Ms. Carter sees a future for the South Bronx, one of cooperation, consideration and green spaces.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/bogardandhoffman/2016/11/29/on-resilience-how-majora-carter-risked-it-all-lost-it-all-and-bounced-back/#74e87bef6bdd is a more recent article where she speaks of her weaknesses and strengths and continues to fight for environmental justice in compromised communities. “We are all responsible for the world that we create. . .we have nothing to lose and everything to gain” (Carter, TedTalk).

Annotated Bibliography

Villalobos, Briana.Intersectional Ecofeminism: Environmentalism for Everybody. IWW Environmental Unionism Caucus. February 2017.

The author looks at the 2017 Women’s March that brought out over 2.5 million women and     families to stand up for a myriad of issues regarding women and the environment. She           asks the reader if the gathering of diverse people during the march is enough to propel and     maintain the movement toward a feminist environmental approach, addressing not just           middle and upperclass white women, but the more significantly marginalized communities       of color.

3 thoughts on “Intersectional Ecofeminism

  1. Hi Tari.
    I liked your approach to this week’s blog and your ability to integrate your own feelings and personal experiences as a way to bring understanding to a complex term. I also loved that you open with Beverly Daniel Tatum and wanted to share another appropriate quote from, The Complexity of Identity: “Who Am I?” I think mimics this weeks subject of intersectionality and even incorporates your (and others) complex “ism’s”. She writes, This “looking glass self” is not a flat one-dimensional reflection, but multi-dimensional. How ones radical identity is experienced will be mediated by other dimensions of oneself: male or female; young or old; wealthy, middle-class, or poor, gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender, or heterosexual; able-bodied or with disabilities; Christian, Muslim, Jewish, Buddhist, Hindu, or atheist.” (Tatum 1). What a great essay on the sense of self and the intersecting forces that defines us. You also clearly define the intersectional role of ecofeminism. The main idea I took away from this week’s topic is that ecofeminism is intersectional in a way that doesn’t see oppression as a hierarchy rather an interconnected web of humans and nonhumans that have different oppressions. Its in this way I have come to realize ecofeminist have an intersectional approach to creating equality among all of us, human and nonhuman. I also wanted to mention the inclusion of the Ted talk in your blog this week. I found Majora Carter’s speech incredibly moving not just because of the obvious strong emotion in her delivery but in the message she conveyed. She voiced the concerns of so many women (men, and children) that honestly go unheard. Just as countries of the Global North and South have been silenced, people in our own country have been silenced because they are viewed as disposable. I was so happy to see Carter be so passionate and raise awareness to a serious issue.

    Works Cited
    Tatum, Beverly Daniel. The Complexity of Identity: “Who Am I?”. 27 March 2020 .

  2. Hi Tari,
    I like the quote you used to start of your blog because I think it sums up what intersectionality is very well along with the pictures you used. it is clear that you have a very good idea of what intersectionality is. This topic is very important because women face problems every day. Just like you said it is all the “isms” that they have to worry about. I appreciate you sharing your own personal experiences that you have gone through in your own life as a way to show that these situations are real, and they happen every day whether we see them or not. You also took past experiences that you saw with you parents and used them as a way to assure that they would not happen to you and you are assuring that it does not happen to your own children as well. I think that is amazing and I will be honest I was not familiar with intersectionality before this week, but I have leant that it is something that can be powerful. I also think that the work Majora Carter has done is truly incredible. I will have to watch her Ted talk one day because reading your summary or her and they work she has done I can tell that she is an incredible woman. It has been amazing to see how much ecofeminism can play into. Feminism alone can be so powerful but combing that with environmental justice and how the two are linked is really interesting. Just like intersectionality and when you apply it to ecofeminist ideas you can see how over decades or changes in society there are still some aspects of women and nature shining through today that were seen back then.

  3. Greetings Tari.
    Your intention to bring non-white women to the fore front as a white woman with good intentions, runs counter to a critic of intersectionality Naomi Zack. “Women of color are only heard in white feminist discourses ‘if willing to present them selves as representatives of this or that disadvantaged racial or ethnic group and have lost the ability to be heard by white women as women'” (Anna Carastathis 311) If Zack is correct, then the podcast has lost its targeted group. Monnica Williams agrees with Zack. “True feminism has the power to transform society, but white feminism (white supremacy in disguise) exists to promote middle-class and affluent white women comforts.” It only recognizes women of color voices to further its aim, while failing to address intersectionality of racial, economic, and sexism experiences. It misses the needs of dis-empowered women, like not caring about the missing indigenous women, or fighting for paid maternity leave. I ask, a podcast in the 21st century? Zack argues – “intersectionality may indeed overcome essentialist constructions of identity, politically it leads to fragmentation of women that precludes common goals..” (311) as seen in the women’s march in early 2017. White women were accused of dominating the planning and execution of the march. How can we bridge this divide? Perhaps if ecofeminists could divide their time spent in the environment with environmental issues affecting people of color, other feminists would pay attention.
    bridget.
    Citation. Carastathis, Anna. The Concept of Intersectionality in Feminist Theory. Umassd.
    Williams, Monnica.Ph.D. How White Feminist Oppress Black Women. chacruna.net.January 2019.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *