The Oppression of Women and Animals

Carol Adams

The difficulty that one faces when trying to awaken our culture to care about the suffering of a group that is not acknowledged as having a suffering that matters, is the same one that a meditation such as this faces. How do we make those whose suffering doesn’t matter, matter?” (Adams p 6).

what is being sold?what is being sold?

Genocide. A word that demands to be defined and yet struggles to be understood. I read A Problem from Hell by Samantha Power when it was first published. Or, I should say, I read half of it. It was a monster of a non-fiction and its subject matter was something I wanted to comprehend on a deep emotional level and found difficult to read in both the continual genocidal atrocities described and the extreme political nature of the word and how impossible it is for political leaders to claim it. Why? Because if they state it, they must do something about it. There in lies the rub. I believe the same is true for abuse of women and animals in todays culture. If we don’t speak about it, it isn’t happening and we can pretend it doesn’t affect us as individuals and we can overlook it. Or as Adams so succinctly puts it, “Genocide, itself, benefits from the politics of the dismissive” (p 5)

The three images above were chosen due to their long term impact on me as a woman and human. The ‘Bingo Wings’ are the imitation of the popular truckers mud flaps with profiles of what appear to be naked Barbies (unobtainable dimensions). I’ve always found them extremely distasteful when I spot them on large and small trucks. To then use that profile to sell animal parts takes another step into darkness. What Adams describes in the reading, the absent referent, is clearly visible here. It is the joining of objectification of women’s bodies with objectification of a dead animal part. Where once there was someone, the chicken, now there are just edible inanimate parts, the wings. This, in one image, destroys two sentient beings and heralds sexism and speciesism as the way to a man’s humanity and stomach.

The following two images, regarding hamburgers are even more distasteful and sexist. To use an image of a woman’s legs, spread open with a man apparently delivering a burger from her vagina?? How is this even acceptable? Not only do we see objectification of the female, we see dissection of the body: legs and implied vagina and womb only. Ground cow parts made into a meal for a man.  And the other advertisement doesn’t even need an image of a woman or any of her severed body parts. The suggestion of what she would say regarding, not the burger but the penis, is reprehensible. That society chooses to link women and animal oppression in such violent, vile images is something I will never agree with or find amusing or legitimate. As women, we fight yesterday, today and tomorrow for autonomy of body, mind and soul.

Because i live from a Buddhist framework and I see life as one universal whole, duality does not ring true for me. Adams describes how she views humans and non-humans as “…human and animal are definitions that exist in tandem, each draws its power from the other in a drama of circumscribing: the animal defining the human, the human defining the animal”(p 5). It is the artificial patriarchal system that keeps the domination of woman and animal facade in place. All life is precious and demands to be treated as such. It is also the apathy, numbness and spiritlessness of the general population that allows it to continue.

PETA campaign

4 Ways the Animal Rights Movement Uses Human Bodies to Sell Animal Rights

The image above is horrendous on so many levels. A friend works for PETA and he was required to view their videos as part of his interview for the position, but has he seen these types of images? He is considering becoming a vegetarian, but is he considering becoming a misogynist? These images do nothing other than promote the subjugation and violence that continues toward women and animals. Utilizing fetishistic sexual violence against often times nude vulnerable women to shock viewers into giving a damn about animals is perpetuating and adding to violence against women. From my standpoint, this image would have been far superior and memorable toward achieving their goal if, in fact, they had shown elephants being mistreated and/or abused. If their goal is to help animals, why not depict what is actually occurring? And reframing the language associated with the images to factually describe their torture. Or coming to the fight from a place of caring and concern. Aran Stibbe writes, “The animal rights movement, as it exists today, provides a discourse that opposes oppression. Animal rights authors frequently counter the classifications of mainstream discourse by using terms such as “nonhuman animal,” and “other-than-human animal.” They also use inclusive terms such as “being” in, “If a being suffers there can be no moral justification for refusing to take that suffering into consideration”. This is the same “humans are animals” semantic classification used in biological discourse to argue against animal rights. However, in this case the similarities drawn are different, focusing on animals’ ability to suffer and feel pain in the same way that humans can” (p 157).

Adams writes about the ‘War on Compassion,’ “caus(ing) people to fear that beginning to care about what happens to animals will destroy them because the knowledge is so overwhelming” (p 10). Are we, as a species, really so weak and fragile that when it comes to seeing something that is real life as opposed to what has been whitewashed, or should I say, redwashed for our convenience, that we can’t take it? I think and believe that it’s much easier in the long term to see the truth than to hold on to the lie. Human psyches have a great deal more trouble with the lie, because intrinsically we already know what the truth is. And with that knowledge of the truth we can stand a little taller and see a littler clearer. Those times of clarity build character. They may hurt like hell and cause great discomfort, but the inhumanity of a situation sometimes takes precedence  Compassion can take the place of inhumanity, creating an awareness of another’s suffering and the choice to take on the task of change. It’s in all of us. It’s our humanity that make us human.

What is meant by animal rights?

Every conscious being has interests that should be respected. No being who is conscious of being alive should be devalued to thinghood, dominated, used as a resource or a commodity. The crux of the idea known as animal rights is a movement to extend moral consideration to all conscious beings.

Nobody should have to demonstrate a specific level of intelligence to be accorded moral consideration. No one should have to be judged beautiful to be accorded moral consideration. No being should have to be useful to humanity or capable of accepting “duties” in order to be extended moral consideration. Indeed, what other animals need from us is being free from duties to us. (https://www.friendsofanimals.org/program/what-is-meant-by-animal-rights/)

Annotated Bibiography

Stibbe, Aran. “Language, Power and the Social Construction of Animals.” Society and                   Animals, 9:2. 2001, pp 145-162.

Stibbe analyzes the myriad ways language and vernacular is used to dominate and exploit animals in the factory farming industry and animal products industries, such as beef for cows, pork for pig, meat production for murder, leather for skin. In this same way, using negative phrases with animals; ugly cow, stupid dog, greedy pig, big ape, you chicken. This language discrepancy continues to subjugate animals, thereby creating a perpetual lack of care for all animals, not just industrial animal production. Stibbe posits that the general population allows the mistreatment and murder of nonhuman animals and, therefore, can change the vernacular to change the treatment.

 

1,196 thoughts on “The Oppression of Women and Animals

  1. I’m not sure why but this blog is loading incredibly slow for me.
    Is anyone else having this problem or is it a problem on my end?
    I’ll check back later on and see if the problem still exists.

  2. 1xbet относится к числу таких платформ,
    1xbet поэтому её основной домен может быть недоступен для украинских пользователей.

    Here is my blog – 1xbet-a1e5u.buzz

  3. Listen սp, steady pom ρi pі, maths proves ρart іn the
    leading disciplines Ԁuring Junior College, establishing groundwork tο A-Level hіgher calculations.

    In ɑddition bеyond school facilities, emphasize оn maths f᧐r
    avoiɗ frequent pitfalls including inattentive blunders ɗuring assessments.

    Parents, kiasu mode ᧐n lah, solid primary maths guides t᧐ superior STEM understanding
    ρlus tech goals.

    Catholic Junior College ρrovides a
    values-centered education rooted іn empathy ɑnd reality,
    creating аn inviting neighborhood wheгe students flourish academically
    аnd spiritually. Ꮤith а focus on holistic development, tһe college
    оffers robust programs іn humanities аnd sciences, assisted by caring mentors ᴡho inspire lifelong knowing.

    Ӏts lively co-curricular scene, including sports аnd arts, promotes team effort and
    seⅼf-discovery іn a helpful environment. Opportunities fⲟr community service ɑnd global exchanges develop empathy аnd international
    рoint оf views among students. Alumni ⲟften emerge
    as empathetic leaders, geared սp to make meaningful contributions tо society.

    Victoria Junior College ignites creativity
    ɑnd fosters visionary management, empowering students tߋo crеate
    positive change tһrough а curriculum tһɑt sparks enthusiasms
    аnd encourages vibrant thinking іn a picturesque coastal school setting.
    The school’ѕ thorough facilities, consisting of liberal arts discussion гooms, science
    гesearch suites, ɑnd arts efficiency locations,
    assistance enriched programs іn arts, humanities, and sciences that promote interdisciplinary insights аnd academic proficiency.
    Strategic alliances ѡith secondary schools tһrough integrated programs mаke sսre а smooth
    instructional journey, usіng sped up learning paths and specialized
    electives tһat cater tⲟ private strengths ɑnd іnterests.
    Service-learning efforts and interenational outreach
    tasks, ѕuch as international volunteer expeditions ɑnd leadership forums, build caring
    personalities, resilience, аnd а commitment to neighborhood ѡell-ƅeing.

    Graduates lead witһ unwavering conviction and achieve extraordinary success іn universities ɑnd professions, embodying Victoria Junior College’ѕ tradition οf
    supporting imaginative, principled, ɑnd transformative
    people.

    Dօ not mess ar᧐und lah, pair a good Junior
    College alongside maths proficiency fοr
    ensure superior А Levels гesults ɑnd smooth transitions.

    Folks, worry аbout the disparity hor, mathematics groundwork гemains vital in Junior College t᧐ grasping figures, essential ԝithin modern tech-driven economy.

    Օһ mɑn, regardlеss whether establishment гemains fancy,
    math serves as the decisive topic tⲟ building poise іn figures.

    Aiyah, primary maths teaches real-ᴡorld applications like budgeting,
    tһuѕ guarantee your child ցets that properly fгom еarly.

    Mums and Dads, fear the gap hor, maths groundwork іs essential
    аt Junior College to grasping іnformation, vital іn current digital economy.

    Goodness, гegardless tһough institution гemains hіgh-end, math serves аs
    tһe critical discipline tο cultivates poise with calculations.

    Aiyah, primary mathematics educates everyday applications
    including budgeting, tһus ensure your kid getѕ thіѕ properly starting үoung age.

    Hіgh A-level scores lead tο teaching assistant roles іn uni.

    Besides Ƅeyond institution amenities, concentrate օn maths
    to avoiⅾ frequent errors ѕuch аs inattentive errors ɗuring exams.

  4. با سلام و احترام
    پیشنهاد ویژه
    سایت پوکر حرفه ای
    رو جهتوالیبال.
    این سرویس حرفه ای ضرایب عالی و برای پوکر
    دوستان جذابه.
    برای1404 عالی و توصیه ویژه دارم.

    یکی از علاقه‌مندان.

  5. درود و احترام محمد
    حتما امتحان کنید
    سایت پوکر هات
    رو جهت پوکر حرفهای.
    این وبسایت امنیت کامل و برای کاربران ایرانی
    مناسبه.
    ضرایبش بالاست و به نظرم خوبه چک کنید.

    ارادتمند شما.

  6. سلام و عرض ادب
    پیشنهاد می‌دم
    سایت تنیس پیش بینی
    رو در حوزه تهران کازینو.
    این وبسایت خوب تنوع بالا و برای رولت دوستان خوبه.

    برای ایرانی‌ها عالیه و بهتره تست
    کنید.
    ارادتمند شما.

  7. все информацию, включая личную сведения и денежные данные, защищены с
    помощью продвинутых технологий шифрования.

    Here is my page … https://1xbet-gm7ow.top/

  8. وقت بخیر
    به نظرم امتحان کنید
    سایت هات بت
    روبرای بسکتبال.
    این سرویس امنیت بالایی دارهو برای پوکر بازها عالیه.

    به نظرم بهترینه و حتما چک کنید ثبت نام.

    تشکر ویژه.

  9. 늦은 밤에도 편하게 이용할 수 있는 토닥이, 여성만을
    위한 섬세하고 배려 깊은 힐링이 기다리고 있습니다.
    지금 바로 경험해보세요.

  10. درود و احترام علی آقا
    توصیهدارم پلتفرم
    سایت پیش بینی ورزشی
    رو در حوزه ѕport betting.
    این سایت اپ اندروید و іos و برای فرمول یک بت عالیه.

    دوستان معرفی کردنو حتما ثبت نام کنید.

    خدانگهدار رضا.

  11. روز بخیر
    توصیه ویژه
    سایت دنیای هات بت
    رو در حوزه پاسور.
    این پلتفرم امکانات خوبی داره و برای پوکر بازها عالیه.

    از بونوس‌هاش استفاده کردم
    و توصیه ویژه دارم.
    با قدردانی.

  12. با احترام فراوان
    پیشنهاد می‌کنم بررسی کنید
    سایت دنیای هات بت
    رو برای بازی‌های ورزشی.

    این اپ کاربردی ضرایب بالایی داره و برای پاسور بازها
    جذابه.
    بهترین سایت شرط بندی و به نظرم سایت خوبیه امتحان
    کنید.
    با آرزوی موفقیت.

  13. Do you mind if I quote a few of your posts as long as I provide credit
    and sources back to your blog? My blog site is in the exact same niche as
    yours and my users would certainly benefit from some of the information you
    present here. Please let me know if this alright with
    you. Thank you!

  14. Магазины пластмассовых судов с рукПлатформы для продажи и
    http://wooden-design.ru покупки бывшую
    в употреблении вещей.

  15. I was wondering if you ever thought of changing the page layout of your site?
    Its very well written; I love what youve got to say.
    But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better.
    Youve got an awful lot of text for only having 1 or 2 pictures.
    Maybe you could space it out better?

  16. Hi! I know this is kinda off topic but I was wondering
    which blog platform are you using for this site? I’m getting fed up of WordPress because I’ve had issues with hackers and
    I’m looking at alternatives for another platform. I would
    be awesome if you could point me in the direction of a
    good platform.

  17. Listen, moms and dads, ɗon’t mention bo jio hor, famous
    schools focus ᧐n understanding, foг HR or counseling careers.

    Folks, smart tо stay vigilant leh, reputable primary assures balanced
    plans, stopping exhaustion fοr prolonged victory.

    Wow, math acts ⅼike tһe base stone in primary education, aiding kids fߋr
    spatial thinking fߋr building careers.

    Hey hey, Singapore parents, arithmetic proves ρrobably tһe extremely essential primary subject,
    promoting innovation іn challenge-tackling fοr innovative careers.

    Ꭰon’t play play lah, pair a good primary school ԝith mathematics superiority
    to assure elevated PSLE scores аnd smooth transitions.

    Օh no, primary arithmetic educates everyay applications ⅼike financial planning, so guarantee үoսr kid
    grasps tһat riɡht beginnіng young age.

    Ⅾon’t take lightly lah, combine а reputable primary school ԝith math proficiency fоr ensure elevated PSLE marks аs
    wеll as smooth transitions.

    Northshore Primary School οffers a dynamic community concentrated on holistic development.

    Dedicated instructors һelp build positive and capable students.

    Yisjun Primary School ρrovides dynamic education in the north.

    The school builds ѕelf-confidence tһrough programs.

    It’s fantastic for regional accessibility.

    My blog Fuchun Primary School

  18. Hello, I would like to subscribe for this webpage to get newest
    updates, therefore where can i do it please assist.

  19. аккаунт на оригинальном 1xbet сайте будет создана.

    Если ответить кратко, то зеркало 1xbet редко понадобится тем,
    кто юзает софт.

    my web page: https://1xbet-u9ir3.buzz/

  20. It’s great that you are getting ideas from this piece of writing as well as
    from our dialogue made at this time.

  21. The site working on that protection individual information, respect security and create
    a fun, balanced space at 1x bet where anyone can play without
    bothering.

  22. Система отзывов и рейтингов: помогает оценить качество изделий и надежность продавцов перед осуществлением
    http://shopoforum.ru покупки.

  23. Живое казино предоставляет возможность клиентам играть в настольные программы поле
    чудес, и игровые автоматы с настоящими дилерами в.

    Also visit my website; 1xbet зеркало на сегодня

  24. Howdy very cool blog!! Guy .. Beautiful .. Superb ..
    I’ll bookmark your blog and take the feeds also?
    I am happy to search out a lot of helpful information here in the publish, we want
    develop more techniques in this regard, thanks for sharing.

    . . . . .

  25. игры с реальными дилерами включают рулетку, блэкджек,
    1xbet покер и баккару. Фриспины на
    пользующиеся спросом –
    однорукие бандиты.

    Also visit my web site https://1xbet-jtfc9.buzz/

  26. If you desire to take a great deal from this paragraph
    then you have to apply these techniques to your won webpage.

  27. For hottest information you have to visit world wide web
    and on the web I found this site as a most excellent website for hottest updates.

  28. We’re a group of volunteers and starting a new scheme in our
    community. Your web site provided us with valuable information to work on. You’ve done an impressive job and our whole community
    will be grateful to you.

  29. Way cool! Some extremely valid points! I appreciate you
    writing this article and also the rest of the website is
    very good.

  30. Новички, чтоб не рисковать средствами, 1xbet могут
    заключать пари с максимально небольшими ставками.

    Feel free to visit my blog https://1xbet-b2rsc.top

  31. Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed!
    Very helpful info particularly the last part 🙂 I care
    for such information a lot. I was seeking this certain info for a long time.
    Thank you and best of luck.

  32. Hi there to every one, the contents present at this web page are actually amazing
    for people experience, well, keep up the nice work fellows.

  33. It’s great that you are getting thoughts from this piece of writing as well as from our argument made at this place.

  34. в игровом заведении 1xbet игровые автоматы доступны юзерам с компьютера и электронных гаджетов – 1xbet планшетов
    или смартфонов.

    My website: https://1xbet-obuji.top

Leave a Reply to https://1xbet-gm7ow.top/ Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *